News

Thursday, November 19th, 2026

FAI Re Death of Christopher Stuchbury, Donald Dinnie and Brett McCullough [2026] FAI 59 and [2026] FAI 60

Sheriff Lesley Johnston issued her determination following the Fatal Accident Inquiry into the deaths of Christopher Stuchbury, Donald Digby Dinnie and Brett George McCullough on 30 October 2026 at Aberdeen Sheriff Court. Counsel from Compass Chambers appeared for several participants in the inquiry. Peter Gray KC represented Network Rail; Carla Fraser represented the Office of Rail and Road; Mark Stewart KC represented Ove Arup & Partners; and Emma Toner KC (now Emma Fraser KC) represented James Scullion.

The inquiry concerned the derailment of a ScotRail passenger train near Carmont, Aberdeenshire, on 12 August 2020. Following exceptionally heavy rainfall, debris from a drainage system was washed onto the railway track, causing the train to derail while travelling at approximately 73 mph. Three people died as a result of the accident: the train driver, Brett McCullough, conductor Donald Dinnie and passenger Christopher Stuchbury. Six other people sustained injuries.

Following a criminal investigation, Network Rail pleaded guilty in September 2023 to a breach of the Health and Safety at Work etc Act 1974, relating to failures in the construction, inspection and maintenance of drainage infrastructure and adverse-weather planning. It was fined £6.7 million.

The inquiry considered extensive evidence concerning the construction and maintenance of the drainage system, the management of adverse weather and the crashworthiness of the train. In reaching her determination under section 26 of the Inquiries into Fatal Accidents and Sudden Deaths etc (Scotland) Act 2016, the sheriff considered whether reasonable precautions could have been taken which might realistically have avoided the accident or deaths.

Sheriff Johnston identified three reasonable precautions under section 26(2)(e). These concerned the construction of the drainage system by Carillion Construction Limited in accordance with the design prepared by Ove Arup & Partners, the preparation and provision of as-built drawings by Carillion Construction Limited, and Network Rail's compliance with its own requirements for obtaining as-built drawings and a health and safety file. The sheriff noted that, had the drainage system been constructed in accordance with Ove Arup’s design, it would have been capable of accommodating the water flow experienced on the day of the accident. In particular, the sheriff found that an additional earth bund constructed by Carillion, which had not formed part of Ove Arup's design, was a significant cause of the washout. She also identified Network Rail's failure to ensure that the drainage system was constructed properly and in accordance with its design as a contributing defect in a system of working under section 26(2)(f).

The sheriff made further findings under section 26(2)(g), recording circumstances relevant to the deaths, including shortcomings in the inspection of the drainage system, training and procedures for managing extreme weather, and the fact that the train was not required to comply with modern crashworthiness standards. However, she distinguished these findings from reasonable precautions under section 26(2)(e), which required a realistic possibility that the accident or deaths could have been avoided.

Despite identifying reasonable precautions and a contributing defect in a system of working, the sheriff made no recommendations under section 26(1)(b). She considered the extensive safety improvements introduced following the derailment and the progress made in implementing the Rail Accident Investigations Branch's (RAIB) 20 recommendations. Satisfied that the outstanding measures were being actively progressed under the oversight of the Office of Rail and Road, she concluded that no additional recommendations were appropriate.

A separate note, issued on 29 September 2025 and published as [2026] FAI 60, addressed the treatment of the RAIB's investigation during the inquiry. The sheriff declined to adopt wholesale the Norfolk principle, applied in English coroners' inquests, which generally limits reconsideration of matters already investigated by a specialist accident investigation body. She emphasised the wider statutory responsibilities of Scottish fatal accident inquiries while recognising the importance of avoiding unnecessary duplication of expert investigations.

The determination and accompanying note can be found here and here.

Back to News

Contact Us

  • Compass Chambers
    Parliament House
    Edinburgh
    EH1 1RF