Year of Call 2013
Clare has a busy practice in the fields of civil and criminal law. She has appeared in courts at all levels across Scotland and has a reputation for being conscientious and excellent with clients.
With a thriving civil practice, Clare is currently instructed in a large number of complex product liability and medical negligence cases; fatal cases arising from death in custody and road traffic accidents, and employer's liability. Clare has previously successfully pursued and defended personal injury actions involving public liability, occupiers liability, employer’s liability, road traffic accidents, industrial disease and fatal cases.
Clare has successfully represented accused in criminal trials including corporate bodies in health and safety prosecutions and professional individuals charged with financial crime offences. She was recently junior counsel for the first accused in the longest trial in UK legal history (20 months duration), involving charges of fraud and money laundering and requiring the management of thousands of productions and hundreds of witness statements.
Utilising the skills and expertise developed whilst a Senior Lecturer at the School of Law, University of Glasgow, Clare is regularly instructed in non-routine cases that require a broad and deep knowledge of legal principle. Such instructions have been fruitful in developing and extending the law, see McCaffer v Lord Advocate, PF Glasgow and Chief Constable, Police Scotland 2015 S.L.T. (Sh Ct) 44. Clare has also represented the appellant in civil actions involving Freedom of Information and the applicant in Judicial Review. She is regularly instructed in criminal appeals against conviction and sentence.
Clare is the editor of Green's Criminal Law Bulletin and Renton & Brown's Statutory Fraud and Business Regulation.
HMA v McLaren and Others, Glasgow High Court, 2017 - Junior Counsel for first accused in longest trial in UK legal history involving fraud and money laundering charges.
Sangster v HM Advocate 2017 SCCR 119 - Sole Counsel representing Sangster senior in appeal against conviction where the requirement to adopt earlier identification at VIPER was in dispute.
PF v Sweet Dreams (Nelson) Limited, 2015 - Sole Counsel - Represented company accused accused of failure to complay with regulation 10 of the Road Vehicles (Construction and Use) Regulations 1986, who were subsequently admonished.
McCaffer v Lord Advocate, PF Glasgow and Chief Constable, Police Scotland 2015 S.L.T. (Sh Ct) 44 - Sole Counsel in Reparation action. This reparation action sought damages for wrongful detention of the accused. The case was pled on the basis of ECHR rather than common law rights and protections. The pursuer successful argued that the common law protections of immunity from suit and requirements to show malice do not apply where damages are sought for a breach of Article 5 of the Convention.
HMA v Ward and Leyden 2015 - Junior Counsel in evidential hearing re admissibility of "bugged" conversations between co-accused in police station.
HM Advocate v Kennedy and Owen 2014 - Junior Counsel in armed robbery trial.
HM Advocate v McCurdie 2014 - Sole counsel. unanimous acquittal of accused on charge of section 1 of Sexual Offences (Scotland) Act 2009.
Addison v HM Advocate 2014 SCCR 608 - Appeal against conviction based on failure of Solicitor to offer accused option of QC representation at trial
Rondos v HM Advocate 2015 SCCR 39 - Application for leave to appeal to Supreme Court in respect of fraud conviction.
Kupka and Rondos v HM Advocate  HCJAC 37 - Appeal against fraud conviction.
PF v Leonardo Carbiner 2013 - Sole Counsel - Successful representation of Dentist charged with 3 counts of fraud.
P(B) v HMA  HCJAC 139 - Sole Counsel in application to Supreme Court
P(B) v HMA  HCJAC 126 - Sole Counsel - Appeal against extradition.
Compass Chambers is delighted that Mark Stewart QC and Gavin... Read More
The Sheriff’s determination in the Fatal Accident Inquiry into the... Read More
Claire Mitchell of Compass Chambers appeared for the appellant in... Read More